My Return to My Return to the Walter Boys: A Nostalgic Revisit That Left Me... Meh

If you’ve been around for a while, you know I’m a sucker for a good YA throwback. There’s something about revisiting old favorites that feels like catching up with childhood friends—you want to see how they’ve grown, what they’ve been up to, and whether or not they’re still worth your time. So when I heard My Return to the Walter Boys was dropping, I was intrigued. Excited, even. I loved the chaos, charm, and cringe-worthy boy moments of the original The Walter Boys back in the day. But this sequel? Let’s just say my return to My Return to the Walter Boys left me feeling... a little underwhelmed.

Spoiler-Free Thoughts (Mostly):

I’m giving this one a 3.25-star rating. It’s not bad. It’s not great. It lives in that very lukewarm space of “I read it, I didn’t hate it, but I probably won’t think about it again in a month.” That’s not necessarily a terrible thing—especially in the world of YA, where sometimes you just want something light and familiar—but for a book that felt so long-awaited and hyped up by fans of the first installment, this one kinda flopped on the follow-through.

The Nostalgia Factor:

Let’s be honest, nostalgia is a powerful thing. I walked into this book with a full heart, ready to swoon, laugh, and maybe even cry a little. The Walter Boys were once the ultimate YA heartthrobs. You had your pick: the broody one, the sweet one, the goofy one, the bad boy—you name it. Each had his moment. And in the original story, that chaotic house full of boys somehow managed to feel both overwhelming and heartwarming.

In My Return to the Walter Boys, we do get glimpses of that dynamic again. There are sweet callbacks, little moments that remind you why you fell for this crazy group in the first place. But that’s mostly what they are—glimpses. The sparkle, the chaos, the fun? It just doesn’t hit the same.

The Plot: A Bit All Over the Place

Without giving too much away, the sequel tries to juggle a lot of threads: reconnections, relationships, misunderstandings, personal growth. All the classic YA ingredients are there, but they’re not as tightly woven as I hoped. At times, the story felt like it was meandering with no clear destination. I caught myself wondering, “Where is this going?” more than once.

And don’t even get me started on some of the characters’ decisions. I’m all for teenage angst and questionable choices (that’s half the fun of the genre), but some of the drama in this book felt like it was cranked up just for the sake of it, not because it actually served the story. It made it hard to root for certain characters or take their emotions seriously.

Character Development: Hit or Miss

I’ll say this—some characters did get solid development. I appreciated seeing how time had changed a few of the Walter Boys and watching them navigate adulthood (or at least late adolescence). There were moments of maturity, self-reflection, and even vulnerability that felt authentic and earned.

Others? Not so much. Some characters felt stuck in the same tropes they were in during book one, which would’ve been fine if we were still in high school. But with everyone supposedly older and wiser, I expected a little more evolution. There were also a few side characters that could’ve used more page time or depth. They were just... there.

Romance Level: Mildly Spicy, Mostly Sweet

Let’s be real—we’re here for the romance. It’s YA. We want the tension, the swoons, the messy miscommunications and grand gestures. And while My Return to the Walter Boys tried to deliver on that front, it didn’t land as hard as I hoped. Some relationships felt forced. Others felt unresolved. There were a few scenes that almost gave me butterflies, but they were fleeting.

Part of the issue might’ve been the emotional disconnect. Even in the romantic moments, it felt like the characters were holding back—or maybe the writing was. I found myself craving more depth, more inner monologue, more vulnerability. I wanted to feel what they were feeling, not just be told.

Pacing & Structure: Could’ve Been Tighter

This is a big one. The pacing in this book is uneven. Some chapters move quickly, while others feel like they drag on without much payoff. I’m all for a slow burn when it’s done right, but here it felt more like slow... meandering.

The structure itself wasn’t bad—it just didn’t feel cohesive. There were too many plotlines competing for attention, and not all of them got the resolution they deserved. A tighter focus on one or two core arcs might have helped the story feel more impactful.

Final Verdict: For the Fans, Not the First-Timers

At the end of the day, I think My Return to the Walter Boys is a book written for the fans—those of us who read the first book, loved it, and wanted just a little more time in that world. And if that’s you, it might still be worth the read. There are enough callbacks and sweet moments to satisfy a craving for closure.

But if you’re new to the series or hoping for a sequel that elevates the original, this probably won’t be it. It’s a decent read, but it’s not a standout.

Would I reread it? Probably not. Would I recommend it? Only to those who are already invested. Will I still secretly hold out hope for a third book that finally delivers the emotional punch I’m craving? Absolutely.

Have you read My Return to the Walter Boys? Did it meet your expectations or leave you hanging? Let’s talk about it in the comments—or come find me on Instagram or TikTok and let’s scream about it there. Because even when a book lets me down a little, I always love talking about it.

Until next time, happy reading 💛

Click the image to download the FREE fable app and join TTPS